1965 Christmas show: --Johnny Mathis - ""On A Wonderful Day Like Today"" Commercial: Listerine Jimmy O'Neill intro --Johnny Mathis - ""Misty"" --Johnny Mathis - ""Maria"" & ""Tonight Tonight"" (both songs from ""West Side Story"") Commercial break: ABC promo for ""Blue Light"" – series with Robert Goulet --Johnny Mathis – Christmas medley: ""Marshmallow World,"" ""Rudolph, the Red Nose Reindeer"" (with Our Young Generation), ""Winter Wonderland,"" ""Carol Of The Bells""/""Ding Dong"" (with Our Young Generation) and ""Sounds of Christmas"" Commercial: Stri-Dex acne medication (with Jimmy O'Neill). --Johnny Mathis – ""I'll Be Home for Christmas"" --Our Young Generation – ""Hey Look Me Over"" --Johnny Mathis and Our Young Generation – ""The Sweetheart Tree"" (75 seconds) --Johnny Mathis – ""Moon River"" --Johnny Mathis and Our Young Generation – ""Hey Look Me Over"" (closing titles) --Johnny Mathis – ""Oh Holy Night""