In New York, Max catches Cassidy cheating on him and runs away from the ship. Sean pretends he's Mr. Big Shot City Guy who knows everything. Denise takes Jimmy out to lunch with her and her family and a Harvard recruiter.

In New York, Cassidy tells Max she loves him and he returns to the boat. Ashley buys one of Jimmy's paintings at an art exhibit thinking it was painted by the artist Serge.

On the boat, Sean gets paranoid as they near the Bermuda Triangle and thinks that Captain Ballard is an alien. Ashley plagerizes one of Tamira's poems and Tamira catches her.