Dick and Mary visit a psychic together, who claims that the pair are from two different worlds and predicts that Dick will one day up and leave Mary. Horrified at this news, Dick decides to find a replacement boyfriend for her, settling on a man called Gary; who thinks he's actually being offered Dick's position of physics professor. Meanwhile, Sally and Harry decide that if the psychic really knows that they are aliens, then they must kill her, but in a way that isn't possible for her to predict.

Mary está teniendo problemas para lidiar con lo que vio: Dick transformando a Scoochie en un mono. Dick, inevitablemente, le dice la verdad y a ella le cuesta creerle. Eventualmente lo acepta e incluso queda fascinado por él. Cuando todo parece ir bien para Dick, Harry anuncia que su misión ha terminado y que deben dejar la Tierra.