When the Devil ponits out Morgan's new client, Morgan is horrified to discover that she's a 16 year old figure skater on her way to the Olympics...meaning the Devil must have made the deal with the girl when she was 6 years old. Morgan's first challenge is to convince the girl that she made a deal she doesn't even remember, before he can get her to seek redemption. And as they uncover the secrets of her past, they make even darker discoveries.

Medium Laura McKinney has spent the decade since making her deal trying to use her Devil-given powers to find the soul of her dead son. When Morgan contacts her, she refuses to seek redemption until she accomplishes her goal. Morgan tries to convince her that the deal was a sham, and that her powers aren't real, but discovers that Laura may hold the key to contacting his own lost love. Will Morgan have to give up his own dream in order to redeem Laura's soul?

Morgan's client is a tattoo artist who remembers making a deal 10 years earlier...but doesn't remember why. As they slowly uncover the secrets of his past, the client recovers his memories...and the pain that goes with them.

Morgan's client is a woman who sold her soul to be the perfect mother, for reasons that become clear as they uncover her past. As Morgan works to save her, Jeri Slate closes in on Morgan, and seems to be on the verge of uncovering his true identity.

Morgan's client spins him into an alternate reality where he's no longer a collector...which may doom the client's soul.