When Kel accidentally destroys half of the school's yearbook photos, it's up to him and Kenan to rectify the situation. In a rare stroke of luck, Bill Bellamy happens to be in town that week.

Kenan winds up with three dates for the same night, and tries to keep them from discovering each other.

Kenan and Kel become masters of practical joking, until it starts making them suspicious of everything and everyone.