While working for Grandma Callaway, Paige becomes the witness to a dangerous magical family feud going back for generations. The Halliwell sisters try to help Richard Montana end the feud before it escalates any further.

Jason breaks up with Phoebe when he finally learns her and her sisters are really witches. Meanwhile, Richard attempts to free himself of his family's karma, and Piper and Paige try to vanquish a group of Swarm Demons, the last on Chris' list of the most significant threats to Wyatt.

When Phoebe frees a genie from a bottle, she soons finds that she must take the genie's place. Meanwhile, anxious to put Leo and Piper back together, Chris uses Phoebe to make his wish come true, but she takes his instructions too literally.