It's shaping up to be a blue Christmas in the Miller household, with Percy unable to catch a flight home, while Romeo and Louis are sweating his arrival because Gary inadvertently donated to the River Creek House (where Louis lived for a year until he was adopted by the Millers) their dad's most prized possession: the watch his wife gave him before she died, which Romeo and Louis intended to give their father for Christmas. Meanwhile, Mrs. Rogers can't find her Christmas spirit away from the circus.

Romeo tries to learn hypnosis so he he can hypnotize Percy. Accidentally, he hypnotizes Mrs. Rogers into thinking she's a dog and causes a big riot at the park. Meanwhile, Jodie is having trouble making her sculpture for her art class.