Romeo and Louis gets hassled by a bully after performing at school. When Jodi sees the bully messing with her brothers she comes and helps them, and makes fun of the bully. So to get his reputation back, the bully asks for a favor: a date with Jodi. Meanwhile, Jodi makes fun of Gary for being short and he quits the group.

Romeo tries to impress a girl, but when he messes up and thinks he has lost his mojo, his father tells him he should simply introduce himself to her. However, Romeo, determined to give his method another chance, pays no mind to his father's advice. So he takes matters into his own hands and makes an even bigger fool of himself trying to impress her. In another story, Mr. Miller tries to kill a mouse running around in the house, but Gary and Mrs. Rogers want to catch it and release it outside.

Romeo discovers that Gary's swim coach is related to a famous record producer, so he and Louis hesitantly try out for the swim team in an attempt to hustle a connection for the band. The only problem is that Romeo can't swim! Louis' tryout efforts gain him a spot on the team, and the coach offers Romeo an irresistible deal – if he takes lessons from her, she will present their band's demo to her uncle, the record producer. Will a record deal help him overcome his fear? Meanwhile, Mrs. Rogers goes on a spending spree, using Percy's money to buy useless household gadgets, and Jodi must utilize her recently obtained knowledge of Psychology 101 to figure out why.

Romeo and Gary discover that their favorite pro wrestling star, Insane Johnny Blame, is in town to accept an award. The boys slip away from a class field trip and sneak into Johnny's hotel room in an attempt to meet their idol. The wrestler goes ballistic when he finds them in his room and, in the ensuing chaos, the boys accidentally break his award. Ro and Gary manage to escape, but are stunned to learn that Percy has brought Johnny home for dinner. Also, Louis helps Jodie get ready for a date.

Myra creates a Web site for the band; Mrs. Rogers becomes a pet psychic.

Romeo has trouble getting a date for the school dance because of Myra; Percy's cousin Bubba comes to visit, so the Miller family has to be out on alert 'cause everytime ""Bubba"" visits it means at least a week of bad luck.

Romeo denies having a girlfriend in a radio interview; Jodi borrows an outfit from Angeline without asking.