Peanut and Jelly accidentally become separated from their parents at the local fair.

When several objects vanish around the Otter household, Peanut and Jelly become "Sherlock Otters", and try to solve the mysterious disappearances.

Butter is afraid of going to the dentist for her very first check-up, so Peanut and Jelly try to show her that when it comes to dental visits, there's nothing to worry about.

Mayor Jeff tells PB&J the story of the famous explorer Ponce de L'Otter, and his golden telescope which was lost in the lake many years ago. Determined, PB&J set out to search for that lost telescope.

The Otter and Snooty kids open up a babbleberry turnover stand, hoping to strike it rich. Trouble is, they aren't selling a single turnover.