When Gaspar sells Mr. Whiskers some meteor insurance in exchange for a Sugartoad poster, Brandy realizes that what Mr. Whiskers' gained was merely a toaster. She tries to tell Mr. Whiskers and when he finally believes her, he heads off to Gaspar's in order to try to get his poster back, though his attempts yield no results. Mr. Whiskers then asks Brandy for help, in which she suggests that Mr. Whiskers attempt to con Gaspar back in order to retrieve the poster, so Mr. Whiskers employs Ed and the two head off to try to trick Gaspar into giving back the Sugartoad poster.

After taking a survey, Whiskers goes to Lola and Ed to see if he's been stressing Brandy out. When they say he does, they show him and Brandy a tv ad for placid falls, and Brandy decides to give it a chance. However, many obstacles await them, such as a loud restaurant, doom river, and a banjo stringing contest.