The quiet town of Nixa, Missouri is shaken to its core when the local beauty queen and town sweetheart, Jackie Johns, goes missing. When the twenty-year-old turns up dead in a nearby lake, police are left with a town full of suspects.

Tana Woolley wins the title of Miss Rosamond in 1978. But just weeks after moving out to live by herself, the 18-year-old is murdered. But who would want her dead?