When Max makes fun of Becca and Christine for not having social lives, the girls decide something has to be done. Becca gets up the nerve to call a guy named Scott she knew at camp, and invites him to a movie that weekend along with a friend for Christine. Becca is both thrilled and terrified that she might get her first real kiss. Unable to stifle his curiousity and jealousy, Tucker convinces Miles that they should spy on the foursome at the theatre. He discovers he knows Scott from camp as well and that he's a real jerk. Becca gets mad at Tucker when he tries to interfere but when Becca discovers Scott's true personality and her allergy to it, she needs help from Tucker to escape from the jerk and Tucker is happy to oblige.

When Scott Stuckey, the town bully and Becca's former crush, shows up with his gang of skateboarders and tries to kick Tucker and Miles out of the park, Tucker takes the bait and challenges Scott to a skateoff. Becca enlists the help of Gooch, who's a skateboarding expert, but has to think fast when she accidently causes him to sprain his ankle. At first Tucker is furious and believes Becca is sabotauging him in favor of Scott, but when he learns the truth he is more determined than ever to teach Scott a lesson he won't soon forget.