Meena is really excited that her favorite Bahavian singer, Nanoosh, is coming to town, and Cory quickly gets jealous. Meena enters a contest to meet Nanoosh. When Meena gives Cory the postcard to mail, he decides not to mail it, and gives it to Newt instead. When Newt forgets to mail the postcard, Cory is pleased and ready to comfort Meena. However, Meena somehow wins. Cory and Newt pretend they are Bahavian musicians in order to sneak into the studio and stop Meena from kissing Nanoosh. However, it seems that Nanoosh is not what he seems.

While all the other kids at school are getting ready for Saturday's charity carnival, Cory and Newt are checking out girls and rating them, something that annoys Meena. They two of them finally decide to get their act together and they ask the Ashley and Ashley out. That night a Cory's house after watching a movie, Newt refuses to kiss the blonde Ashley and walks out. This causes the girls to leave as well. Newt later reveals that he made a promise to a girl named Jennifer when he was 8, that he would not kiss another girls before he kissed her. When the Ashley's give Cory and Newt another chance, Cory opens a kissing both for Newt and convinces him that Jennifer probably broke the promise, but Newt decides to stick to it. Meanwhile, Sophie becomes a sore winner when she beats Victor in many different games, and he decides to teach her a lesson.