Tia agrees to go to the upcoming Cadillac Tramps concert with Vincent, and Rachael is thrilled to get asked out by Jamie after interviewing him about his recent thievery. Both are highly disappointed, as Tia is labeled a slut for Vincent's claims that he slept with her, and Rachael feels like one after sleeping with Jamie.

After Vincent learns that R.J. will be kicked off the basketball team if he gets into a fight, he deliberately goads him, continuing his lies that R.J.'s sister Tia slept with him. Carol is furious with Penny after learning that thanks to Penny, the entire school believes that she is gay.