While lost in the woods, Fi helps a Bigfoot-like creature remain undetected by humans at the risk of her own life.

Fi investigates an old family friend, John, a former guitar player who's lost the ability to play after receiving a heart transplant, and is showing signs of madness.

Annie and her friends play with a Ouija board that seems to be able to predict the future for real.

Annie and the gang meet an old family friend of Annie's; strange things happen around Annie and the gang resembling bad voodoo.

Molly buys an unusual painting that traps Annie and her friends in, where they encounter the artist himself who's seeking solitude and doesn't want any company.

Molly looks to find her lost ""muse,"" or inspiration, at an Oregon inn where she and her late husband Rick first met and played music together. Jack also is concerned because he doesn't have an interest like music that inspires him. At the restaurant Annie meets a brash young man named Quinn who says he's Molly's muse, sent to help her. He proves his powers on the waitress and a dog. Annie takes him to Molly, but his powers don't work on her. Molly gets depressed and wants to leave without doing a show. Carey finds the dog Quinn made dance earlier thinking it may be the Muse, but now the dog just sits. Quinn admits that this is his first job as Muse. Jack talks to a strange handyman who has been working in their room, and he tells Jack he has to listen for his muse. Molly decides to do the show. On the way out of the inn she mentions the handyman to the owner, who tells her they employ no such person. At the concert something special is revealed to both Molly and Jack.

Alone in the house, Jack believes he's being haunted by his dead neighbor over something he did when he was six years old.

After Ziegler from Exit 13 sends Annie a package that causes Molly and the boys to forget everything about Annie, she desperately tries to refresh their memories.