Creed has been blackmailing people for unknown reasons and his first target is Oscar Martinez.

What dirt did Creed dig up on Andy?

After blackmailing Oscar Martinez and the Nard Dog, Creed decides to blackmail Kelly Kapoor.

The Dunder Mifflin employees have had it with Creed blackmailing them. As a result, they show him interesting facts about Creed.

Michael and Erin meet "Scott's Tots", a group of local teenagers whose college tuition was promised in one of Michael's grand delusions ten years prior. Meanwhile, in Michael's absence, Dwight convinces Jim to start an employee-of-the-month program with the intention of sabotaging Jim.

Holly and Michael turn Andy's business seminar into an improv challenge. Erin and Gabe compete in a board game battle.

Robert California stops by for the first time as CEO and leaves behind a mysterious list that has a line down the middle and every member of the office on either one side or the other. The office members frantically try to figure out what it means. Meanwhile, the new manager Andy faces a crisis.

Pressed to boost the bottom line, Andy finds a novel way to improve sales, while Dwight explores corporate opportunities outside Scranton.

Dwight offers free family portraits, and a stolen diaper leads to a high-speed car chase. With help from David Wallace, Andy goes undercover to try to get his job back. A new business opportunity arises for Robert California.