Buffy and Hildy are invited by Sonny and Isabelle to a singles bar. The pair are ignored by the men, causing Henry to question society's favoritism for attractive people. Feeling like a hypocrite for spurning Amy's advances, he asks her out on a date.

When Ruth insists that Kip indulge a new client, Kip walks out, expecting Henry to follow him.

Kip tries to help Henry spice up a story documenting Ruth nearly discovering the duo's alternate identities.

After Isabelle steals the show from Bob The Comic by singing ""New York, New York"" during his stand-up act, Kip and Henry arrange for her to sing at a night club.