In the wake of the loss of one of the group's members, Lily and Robert spend the day together, leading Lily to take some drastic steps to change her life. Similarly, fellow group member Carla is also jolted by the tragic turn of events and finds herself inspired to shake things up in her ordered domestic existence. Meanwhile, Miller's interest in Lily may run deeper than she understands as she appears to be connected to a larger investigation he is conducting.

While Lily and Detective Miller begin to form a more personal relationship, her dream of having her own vintage clothing boutique is becoming a reality. Meanwhile, ophthalmologist Robert gets fixed up on a blind date and gets a visit from Miller who fears that his diminished vision is a result of a more serious malady. Group member Jorge, who was suicidal because of his tragically small penis, decides to try his hand at stand-up comedy. This leads to a chance meeting with a woman who has a special interest in his "problem."

Robert and Miller begin a strange friendship while trying to find a missing Lily, who doesn't show up for her support group meeting. At the meeting, we learn more about how teenager Adam's troubled home life lead to his suicide attempt. Meanwhile the group leader Dogg arranges for the group to be of service at a senior center. A great idea until Carla decides to bake "special" brownies for the seniors. Finally Miller's patience wears thin with the barrage of harassing phone calls from his credit card company and he decides to take matters into his own hands.