Kibre and Gaffney take on the job of prosecuting a man who is suspected of killing a pedophile, whom was recently paroled from prison.

Kibre and Gaffney must prosecute a nanny accused of killing the baby she was caring for by causing shaken baby syndrome. The only problem is they receive a judge who favors the defense since he was a former legal aid attorney.

Kibre tries a celebrity basketball star accused of raping and murdering his mistress. However, she runs into trouble when the star's wife has a slip of the tongue on the stand.

Kibre prosecutes a man who shot up the bank where he worked, killing the woman responsible for his son being in a coma. She runs into trouble when the man decides to represent himself, and the jury is sympathetic for him.