In order to get her witch's license, Sabrina must complete community service in the Other Realm. She gets a job at the rumor mill, a place where rumors are started, and meets a guy named Dashiell.

Sabrina's plan to balance seeing both Harvey and Dashiell is disrupted when they meet each other by chance. They ask her to choose between them, while a hasty act leads to her being forced to make an even bigger decision.

As Sabrina continues to avoid choosing between Harvey and Dashiell, the pair give her an ultimatum: choose one of them, or neither will stay with her. Meanwhile, her aunts inform that she is finally to receive her witch's license.