16 year old Carter's life is turned upside down when she learns that the mom who raised her is actually her abductor. But after being reunited with her real family, she learns there's more to her kidnapping than meets the eye.

Carter and her new friends plan to trick the police, while an old friend tries to stay in her life, and her relationship with Elizabeth continues to be strained.

The Wilsons try to get justice for Carter's kidnapping, but are tested by secrets.

Carter must deal with new parents, a twin sister and a brand new high school; Carter vows to find the only mother she has ever known.

After learning about the outcome of Lori's trial, Carter wants to get to know her brother; David and Elizabeth fight over Lori's latest surprise.

Carter and Ben face off over secrets and lies; Elizabeth learns the truth about Carter; Carter must fight to earn trust.