Cast 36

1. 

   Kimberly Williams-Paisley

   Ida Graber

2. 

   Tammy Blanchard

   Amy Roberts

3. 

   Fay Masterson

   Jill Green

4. 

   Madison Mason

   Levi Brennaman

5. 

   Gary Graham

   Henry Taskey

6. 

   Darcy Rose Byrnes

   Rebecca Knepp

7. 

   Karley Scott Collins

   Katie Graber

8. 

   Eugene Byrd

   Danny

9. 

   Bruce Nozick

   Leonard

10. 

    Amy Sloan

    Rachel Knepp

11. 

    John Churchill

    Charlie Roberts

12. 

    Madison Davenport

    Mary Beth Graber

13. 

    Matt Letscher

    Gideon Graber

14. 

    Eric Nenninger

    State Trooper

15. 

    Willow Geer

    Judith

16. 

    Christopher Curry

    Minister

17. 

    Kate Fuglei

    Shelly

18. 

    Jim Metzler

    Sheriff

19. 

    Bob Rumnock

    Reporter

20. 

    Emilee Wallace

    Teacher Ruth

21. 

    Jessica Dickey

    Melinda

22. Chloe Madison

    Sarah Knepp

23. 

    Taylor Ann Thompson

    Hannah

24. 

    Trevor Thompson

    Jacob

25. 

    David Mazouz

    Andy Roberts

26. 

    Dale Wade Davis

    Rachel's Husband

27. 

    Joel Schmidt

    Melinda's Husband

28. David Curtis

    Amish Elder

29. 

    Sammy Jack

    Knepp Boy #1

30. Gabriel Welch

    Knepp Boy #2

31. Elijah Tadros

    Ryan Roberts

32. 

    Caleb Babcock

    Schoolboy (uncredited)

33. 

    Daphne Blunt

    Lilly (uncredited)

34. Isabella Interian

    Lydia (uncredited)

35. Marcus Shultz

    Knepp Teenager (uncredited)

36. Johnny Wilson

    Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)

Crew 6