Cast 129

1. 

   Donald Trump

   Self (archive footage)

2. 

   Mindy Robinson

   Grace The Reporter

3. 

   Dywayne Thomas

   John Murphy

4. 

   Lia Marie Johnson

   (archive footage)

5. 

   Shane Ryan-Reid

   Brandon

6. 

   Sabrina Culver

   Stacy Miller

7. Ice Cool

   Chad

8. 

   Ken Holmes

   Miguel 'Snakeskin' Perez

9. 

   Cris Cochrane

   Samael 'Sam' Dubhan

10. Leah Coonce

    Karen

11. 

    Barack Obama

    Self (archive footage)

12. 

    Josh Outzen

    Ted Bundy Admirer

13. Gary Lee Vincent

    Agent Walker

14. 

    Mark Valeriano

15. Michael Lake

    Jared Oakley

16. Marc Hockl

17. 

    Sophia Cacciola

    Kelly Thompson (segment: Cable 54 News - Why Do Killers Kill?)

18. 

    Brandi Aguilar

    Piper Lopez

19. Kelley Wilson Robinson

    Roxie

20. Glenn Berggoetz

    Bill Carl

21. Emily McKinley Hill

22. 

    Jason Impey

    Officer Joe Newton

23. 

    Acadia Colan

    Serena

24. Richard Chandler

    Biker

25. Tony Newton

26. Navah Raphael

    Parker Rhodes

27. Delaney Vallese

    Victim's Sister

28. Steven Perillo

    Interviewee

29. Rosann Ferrier

    Jan Parsons - Criminal Psychology

30. Hunter Otto

    Hunter Schmidt

31. Bryden Elliott DiGennaro

    Victim's Friend

32. 

    Derrick Gilbert

    Young kid

33. Gant Montgomery

    Officer Thompson

34. Urszula Makowska

    Interviewee

35. Chuck Chapman

    Johnny Starr

36. Thomas Gangstad

    Crazy fan

37. Roberto Ragone

    Detective Mark Agnello / President of Necrophiliacs Anonymous

38. Axle Gunn

    Detective

39. Travis Lance Sosa

    Robert

40. Josh Hayes

    Dr. Ian Gensuse (segment "Sue")

41. Klaudia Lucia Wyzykiewicz

    Actress

42. Val Tannuzzi

    Alejandra Gomez

43. Nick Charles

    Serial Killer Fan

44. Maude Michaud

    Sara (segment "Made For You")

45. 

    Dean Houlihan

    Simon / Killer

46. Steve Mack

    Brandons Nephew

47. O'Neil Thomas

    Interviewee

48. Kevin Lapham

    Det. Wilson Brown

49. 

    Luc Bernier

    Martin (segment "Made For You")

50. Chris Miller

    Deranged Interviewer

51. Spencer Mathis

52. Roman Brion

    V (Segment "Fear the Ghetto Killer")

53. Iris Crenshaw

    Criminal Psychologist

54. Justine Colan

    Cousin #2

55. Dena Navarroli

    Michaela Lillestol

56. Lilith Singson

57. Suzana Trifkovic

    Victim's Friend

58. Carly Richardson

    Sam

59. Scott Geiter

    Family Friend

60. Chris Pinto

    Miles Thornbush

61. Rose Pendleton

62. Scott Bray

    Tom Smith

63. Gino DiNardo

64. Connor Komoroski

    Ted Bundy Fan

65. Petey Hixson

    Killer in Van #2

66. Teresa Tuttle

    Reid's mom

67. Robert Alesandro

    Max Caulfield

68. 

    Gregor Collins

    Jeronomo Rozebush

69. Jeynelle Dean-Hayes

    Sue Tralfero (segment "Sue")

70. Bradley Louis Kramer

    Louie

71. Vincent Maeder

    Ralph Witkins

72. Tom Culo

    Doctor

73. 

    Lluvia Almanza

74. Amanda Marie

75. Nancy Pinto

    Annabelle Thornbush

76. Krister Twizz Forsberg

    Victim

77. Judith Etzelstorfer

    Witness

78. Vex X. Starskream

    Perpetrator

79. Timothy Patrick O'Neill

80. Jimmy Champane

    Mike (segment "Poetry in That")

81. 

    Luke Y. Thompson

82. Jagger Trouant

    Drew Holland

83. Jerry O' Nofre

    Conspiracy Guy

84. Stefanie Slack

    Girl in Van #2

85. Devin Williams

    Jimmy

86. Eddie Forsberg

    Young Brandon

87. Rhys Griffin

    Adrian

88. Brenda Carey

    Harper Bennet

89. Shelley Fairbanks

    Zoey 'FreaqShow' Peterson

90. Holly Ruth Bailey

    Karen

91. Pierce Bunch

    James Hartley

92. Alan McLoughlin

    Alan

93. Doug Christman

94. Branden Vives

    Interviewee

95. Ralitsa Chobanova

96. Dean Michael Smith

    J.R. Wilson

97. Dwight Cooke

    Junior (segment "Cruel Yule")

98. Amish

99. Bella Farris

    Victim's Sister

100. Larry McKenzie

101. Cheyanne Allison

102. Eric Cire

     Dave (segment "Poetry in That")

103. Kirse Cosey

     young Reid

104. Anthony Caligiuri

105. Enya d'Entremont

     Cousin #1

106. Beatrix Victoria

     Victim (segment "Cruel Yule")

107. Rachael Kim-Ainsworth

     Reporter (voice)

108. Ashley Smith

     Ashley

109. Carla Dawn d'Entremont

     Cameron Patrick

110. Brandon Marc Powers

     Owen Walsh

111. Abbie Williams

     Ruby Collingwood

112. Tessa Hold

113. Saveaya Oz

     Pearl

114. Eveline Dunlap

115. Jenna Renee

     Victim

116. Samari Clark

     Roe

117. Jean Joseph

     Jean

118. Carl d'Entremont

     Firsherman

119. Paolo Vanoli

     Brandon Fan (segment "Brandon Lives")

120. Greg Boyea

     Ron Stone

121. Jeremy Maury

     Jeremy

122. 

     Jennifer White

123. Aleksandra Brown

     Girl in Van #1

124. Tina Matasari

     Raped Girl (segment "Brandon Lives")

125. Michael Andrick

126. Amanda DaSilva

127. Garrett D. West

     Danny Stevens

128. 

     Corey Seaver

     Peyton Prescott

129. Hunter Smith

     Hunter

Crew 31