E.J. slips Jeff a copy of Sakelik’s police personnel file which reveals that Sakelik was taken into custody by Child Protective Services 25 years ago after being found with other abandoned children at a house in Arrowhead. Jeff and Skye locate the house and question the owner, Annabelle. Sakelik tracks Jeff and Skye to the house and they barely escape with their lives. Stuart continues to befriend Roger. Meanwhile, on the television show, Kelly finds a lock of Meadow’s hair in the trunk of Billy’s car.

E.J. dà a Jeff una copia del file di Sakelik. Jeff e Skye allora iniziano le indagini, ma ben presto la stessa Sakelik li raggiunge e cerca di fermarli. Nel frattempo, Stuart e Roger approfondiscono il loro legame di amicizia.