Season Regulars 5

1. 

   Anthony Mackie

   John Doe

2. 

   Stephanie Beatriz

   Quiet

3. 

   Samoa Joe

   Sweet Tooth

4. 

   Will Arnett

   Sweet Tooth (voice)

5. 

   Thomas Haden Church

   Agent Stone

Guest Stars 13

1. 

   Jason Mantzoukas

   Preacher

2. Anthony Mackie Jr.

   Young John

3. 

   Lena Clark

   Goddess Janice

4. 

   Sharon Landry

   Wandering Woman

5. 

   Alex Aschinger

   Jeffrey

6. 

   Jeronimo Spinx

   Driving Holy Man

7. Av Ayoung

   Thirsty Holy Man

8. Dennis Fay Keiffer

   Drunk Holy Man

9. 

   Ned Yousef

   Holy Mechanic

10. James Cusimano

    Holy Cupbearer

11. 

    Kevin Reid

    Gunshot Holy man

12. Sean Braud

    Hatchet Holy Man

13. Aaron D. Parker

    Moaning Cross Man

Crew 4