After finding out that her grandma's café might have to close for good, Holly attempts to save the beloved family business by hosting an Open Mic.

Holly is jealous when she discovers that Amy and Piper are trying out for cheerleading together, so she tries to sabotage their developing friendship.

Mayor Flaherty blames the Open Mic Night for the destruction of Farmer Dodge’s giant cucumber, prompting Holly and her friends to search for the real culprit.

Worried that Piper might beat her in the Pickle Pageant, Holly must decide between following other people's advice on how to win or being true to herself.

As punishment for lying about who destroyed the cucumber, Holly and Robbie are forced to spend their day building a chicken coop for Farmer Dodge.

After discovering that the pickle factory’s faulty filtration system is contaminating the nearby creek, Holly defies her mother to expose the truth.

Holly and Piper both plan birthday parties on the same day, and when Piper refuses to change the date of her party, Holly attempts to upstage her.

Upset about disappointing her mom and possibly losing her best friend after the birthday party incident, Holly runs away to Chicago with Tyler.

After discovering that Piper and her mom are behind on their rent and will have to move away, Holly goes to extreme measures to help her new friend.