Cast 58

1. 

   Joshua Zeman

   Himself

2. 

   Barbara Brancaccio

   Herself

3. Bill Ellis

   Himself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State

4. Dorothy D'Eletto

   Herself - Archivist & Researcher

5. 

   Geraldo Rivera

   Himself - Reporter (archive footage)

6. Karen Schweiger

   Herself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother

7. David Navarro

   Himself - Former Newscaster

8. Donna Cutugno

   Herself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer

9. Ralph Aquino

   Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD

10. Bobby Jensen

    Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD

11. Ernie Anastos

    Himself - Reporter (archive footage)

12. Andre Rand

    Himself - Suspect

13. Jim Callaghan

    Himself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle

14. Jim Dolan

    Himself - Reporter (archive footage)

15. Theresa Doyle

    Herself - Searcher for Jennifer

16. Ed Armstrong

    Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother

17. Sean Hughes

    Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage)

18. Peter Hughes

    Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Father

19. Holly Cederholm

    Herself - Holly Ann Hughes's Mother

20. Ken Schweiger

    Himself - Jennifer Schweiger's Father

21. John O'Brien

    Himself - Reporter, Staten Island Advance

22. Duane Felton

    Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand

23. Larry Simon

    Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand

24. William L. Murphy

    Himself - Staten Island District Attorney

25. Trina Cutugno

    Herself - Donna's Daughter

26. Devin Cutugno

    Himself - Donna's Son

27. Jimmy Rassias

    Himself - Former Clerk, Port Richmond Deli

28. Kristine Gosling

    Herself - Det. Sgt. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD

29. Luis Rivera

    Himself - Retired Canine Officer, NYPD

30. Frank Saez

    Himself - Ret. Det. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD

31. Jack Whitford

    Himself - Stapleton Civilian Observation Patrol

32. Thomas Jenkins

    Himself - Staten Island Resident

33. Bob Graham

    Himself - Acquaintance of Rand

34. Frances Auriti

    Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer

35. Tracy Begley

    Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer

36. Glenn Chapman

    Himself - Former Reporter, Staten Island Advance

37. Leonard D'Alessandro

    Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD

38. Martha Hinton

    Herself - Witness

39. Frank Marchionne

    Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD

40. Tanya Goodson

    Herself - Witness

41. Rita Dimartino

    Herself - Aunt of Alice Pereira

42. Charles G. Muskett Sr.

    Himself - Former Minister

43. Steve Bogen

    Himself

44. Patricia Caridad

    Herself

45. Robert Caruso

    Himself

46. Greg Cusick

    Himself

47. Charlie Cutugno

    Himself

48. Daniel M. Donovan Jr.

    Himself - District Attorney for Richmond County

49. Marla Dziergowski

    Herself

50. Robert Foster

    Himself

51. Melissa Grace

    Herself

52. Judah Lazarus

    Himself

53. Bruce Meyersen

    Himself

54. Thomas Micol

    Himself - Staten Island Resident

55. Carolyn Muskett

    Herself

56. Marie Piazza

    Herself

57. Lorraine Shanley

    Herself

58. Brett Straniere

    Himself

Crew 14