Martin meets Ted for the first time in the bathroom at Val and Eddie's wedding, while Benny watches unamused. Val tries to convince Martin to step outside his comfort zone; and Eddie gets an ear full from Ted after a few rounds of whiskey.

Valerie pops over to Martin's with a couple of unexpected guests. Martin resists Valerie's advice to reach outside of his comfort zone. Ted bumps into Martin on a lunch break.

Martin and Ted get unwanted advice from Val and Eddie as they each get ready to go to a Yankees game. Eddie and Val discuss looking for a new place to live. Benny invites Martin and Ted to an art exhibit.

Martin and Ted bond at a gallery exhibit. Val and Eddie have a disagreement over vaginas and Benny lends some helpful insight.

Benny shows Eddie and Val a high-rise apartment a bit out of their price range. Ted wants advice on a thank you gift for Martin. Eddie is less than happy about Ted's "transformation" but Benny hatches a plan to bring peace.

Martin receives some surprising news. Ted has troubles at work but finds solace in co-worker Henny Hernandez. Eddie suffers from the aftermath of being a hero at work and Benny tries to comfort Martin.

Martin wakes up after a night of binge drinking with a house guest. Benny tries to fill in the gaps while Val drops by with some surprising news. Eddie and Ted try to cope with being a man.

Martin deals with writer's block. His relationship with Ted continues to strain while Ted gets closer to Henny. Benny tries to ignite Martin's memory; Eddie is weary of sharing good news with Martin and Val opens up to Henny about her pregnancy.

Ted gives Martin a long over due visit. Benny seeks some creative help. Eddie and Val struggle with impending parenthood and Henny is full of great ideas. Season one finale.