Martin meets Ted for the first time in the bathroom at Val and Eddie's wedding, while Benny watches unamused. Val tries to convince Martin to step outside his comfort zone; and Eddie gets an ear full from Ted after a few rounds of whiskey.

Valerie pops over to Martin's with a couple of unexpected guests. Martin resists Valerie's advice to reach outside of his comfort zone. Ted bumps into Martin on a lunch break.

Martin and Ted get unwanted advice from Val and Eddie as they each get ready to go to a Yankees game. Eddie and Val discuss looking for a new place to live. Benny invites Martin and Ted to an art exhibit.

Martin and Ted bond at a gallery exhibit. Val and Eddie have a disagreement over vaginas and Benny lends some helpful insight.

Benny shows Eddie and Val a high-rise apartment a bit out of their price range. Ted wants advice on a thank you gift for Martin. Eddie is less than happy about Ted's "transformation" but Benny hatches a plan to bring peace.

The gang gathers for dinner with a few unexpected guests. Ted worries about how his father will react to his friendships with Martin and. Ted's neighbor Glen is confused about Ted's living situation.

Martin receives some surprising news. Ted has troubles at work but finds solace in co-worker Henny Hernandez. Eddie suffers from the aftermath of being a hero at work and Benny tries to comfort Martin.

Martin wakes up after a night of binge drinking with a house guest. Benny tries to fill in the gaps while Val drops by with some surprising news. Eddie and Ted try to cope with being a man.

Ted gives Martin a long over due visit. Benny seeks some creative help. Eddie and Val struggle with impending parenthood and Henny is full of great ideas. Season one finale.